NAIA Hall of Fame (1972)
Texas Wesleyan Athletic Hall of Fame (1976)
Gof Coaches Association of America Hall of Fame (2009)
  Bobby Cornett
Texas Wesleyan Athletic Hall of Fame (1986)
Golf Coaches Association of America Hall of Fame (2010)
NAIA Hall of Fame (2012)
  Ian Leggatt
NAIA Hall of Fame (2011)
Texas Wesleyan Athletic Hall of Fame (2019)

Kevin Millikan
Texas Wesleyan Athletic Hall of Fame (2024
  Danny Mijovic
Texas Wesleyan Athletic Hall of Fame (2011)
NAIA Hall of Fame (2011)

Texas Wesleyan Athletic Hall of Fame Members (9)

---

O.D. Bounds
Bobby Cornett
Doug Higgins
Ray Jefferson
Kevin Millikan
Danny Mijovic
Benny Passons
Jerry Wood
Robert Wood
Mike Krsnak